Motive is an essential ingredient in case of circumstantial evidence: SC acquits man of Section 302 IPC after 15 years
INTRODUCTION In a remarkable judgment passed by B.V. Nagarathna, J. and Satish Chandra Sharma, J., the Hon’ble Apex Court on 04.06.2025 acquitted a youth convicted under Section 302 and 201 IPC, 1860 by holding that the circumstantial evidence on record was not consistent and left a reasonable possibility of an alternate outcome i.e. of innocence of the appellant on the charges of murder and illegal usage of fire arm. The Hon’ble Court observed that it was a time-tested proposition of law that when a Court is faced with a situation wherein two different views appear to be reasonably possible, the matter is to be decided in favour of the accused. The benefit of counter possibility goes to the accused in such cases. The Court while acquitting the appellant has held that in law, there is [Read More]